VCT PERFORMANCE
   
Table of Internal Rates of Return for current VCTs based on latest published Net Asset Values (figures only relate to investors who purchased the first issue of shares)
 

 

We are publishing these tables as a contribution from an independent source to the debate on how VCT fund managers have performed. To this end we compare the amount invested in a share against the distribution stream plus the latest net asset value. Dividends up to the end of the 1999/00 tax year are gross. As we are measuring fund manager performance the tax breaks are not relevant. However, because of the issues mentioned in the note following the table, we do not believe that conclusions can yet be drawn from the data to  judge the performance of fund managers.

Last Updated: 3 March 2008

GENERALIST FUNDS STARTED IN TAX YEARS 95/96 AND 96/97
Venture Capital TrustFunds Raised (£m)Net Asset Value (pence)Issue Price (pence)Total Return
(Net Asset Value plus dividends)
(pence)
First trading dayDate of last published NAV figureTotal Return Internal Rate of Return (%)
Close Brothers VCT Plc24.20112.20100207.0004/04/9631/12/078.4
Baronsmead VCT plc10.8090.00100180.1013/11/9531/10/076.4
Northern VCT plc43.3081.60100152.5001/11/9530/09/074.4
British Small Cos VCT plc16.20100.70100140.7004/04/9631/12/073.4
Close Brothers Protected plc27.9096.90100131.9004/04/9730/09/073.1
Quester VCT plc32.9030.5010081.3004/04/9630/11/07(2.6)
Oxford Technology VCT plc32.1046.0010073.8004/04/9731/08/07(3.1)
Guinness Flight VCT plc4.9050.0010063.5004/04/9630/11/07(4.3)


GENERALIST FUNDS STARTED IN TAX YEARS 97/98 AND 98/99
Venture Capital TrustFunds Raised (£m)Net Asset Value (pence)Issue Price (pence)Total Return
(Net Asset Value plus dividends)
(pence)
First trading dayDate of last published NAV figureTotal Return Internal Rate of Return (%)
Baronsmead 2 VCT plc45.20107.50100168.4002/04/9831/01/086.5
Downing Protected VCT 1 plc9.80108.90100157.1019/05/9730/06/075.2
Close Brothers Development VCT plc14.6097.40100131.2027/01/9930/09/073.6
Elderstreet VCT plc15.1080.40100116.9018/05/9830/06/072.1
Noble VCT plc6.5071.22100117.8709/12/9631/01/081.9
Crown Place VCT plc40.0042.6010073.1008/04/9830/09/07(4.1)


AIM BASED STARTED IN TAX YEARS 95/96 AND 96/97
Venture Capital TrustFunds Raised (£m)Net Asset Value (pence)Issue Price (pence)Total Return
(Net Asset Value plus dividends)
(pence)
First trading dayDate of last published NAV figureTotal Return Internal Rate of Return (%)
Pennine AIM VCT plc4.6062.20100147.3004/04/9631/12/075.0
AIM Distribution Trust plc (the)17.6055.70100111.5003/05/9631/01/081.4


AIM BASED STARTED IN TAX YEARS 97/98 AND 98/99
Venture Capital TrustFunds Raised (£m)Net Asset Value (pence)Issue Price (pence)Total Return
(Net Asset Value plus dividends)
(pence)
First trading dayDate of last published NAV figureTotal Return Internal Rate of Return (%)
Close Brothers AIM VCT plc10.1059.40100123.8017/03/9831/01/083.4
Rensburg AIM VCT plc23.5070.7010095.7010/06/9931/12/07(0.6)
Pennine Downing AIM VCT plc10.2071.0010091.0018/05/9831/12/07(1.1)
Bluehone AIM VCT plc17.0052.0010084.9009/12/9831/01/08(2.2)


GENERALIST AND HYBRID STARTED IN TAX YEAR 99/00
Venture Capital TrustFunds Raised (£m)Net Asset Value (pence)Issue Price (pence)Total Return
(Net Asset Value plus dividends)
(pence)
First trading dayDate of last published NAV figureTotal Return Internal Rate of Return (%)
Matrix Income & Growth 4 VCT plc33.00120.40200131.9008/03/9931/10/073.4
Northern 2 VCT plc24.3089.10100124.5021/04/9931/10/072.9
Foresight VCT plc24.3064.808169.8002/11/9930/09/07(4.4)
Talisman First VCT plc5.3053.3010053.3004/04/0031/03/07(8.6)


GENERALIST AND HYBRID STARTED IN TAX YEARS 00/01
Venture Capital TrustFunds Raised (£m)Net Asset Value (pence)Issue Price (pence)Total Return
(Net Asset Value plus dividends)
(pence)
First trading dayDate of last published NAV figureTotal Return Internal Rate of Return (%)
ProVen VCT plc22.00104.70100181.4010/04/0031/01/088.8
Baronsmead 3 VCT21.90120.80100154.1030/01/0130/11/077.1
Close Technology and General VCT plc13.20112.40100149.4017/01/0130/09/076.7
Matrix Income & Growth 2 VCT plc13.10104.70100125.5011/07/0031/10/073.3
Income & Growth VCT plc (the)41.70100.40100116.9015/11/0031/12/072.3
Aberdeen Income and Growth VCT plc21.9077.50100106.3011/04/0030/11/070.9
Chrysalis VCT plc6.0088.00100105.0004/04/0131/10/070.8
Noble Health Fund VCT plc7.6079.3010092.8026/03/0131/12/07(1.1)
Oxford Tech 2 VCT plc7.6068.0010074.0005/04/0031/08/07(4.1)
Quester VCT 4 plc53.0045.7010051.6010/11/0031/10/07(9.5)
Gateway VCT plc10.7041.9010042.9030/06/0030/09/07(11.1)


AIM BASED STARTED IN TAX YEARS 00/01
Venture Capital TrustFunds Raised (£m)Net Asset Value (pence)Issue Price (pence)Total Return
(Net Asset Value plus dividends)
(pence)
First trading dayDate of last published NAV figureTotal Return Internal Rate of Return (%)
Singer & Friedlander AIM 3 VCT plc33.0078.5010085.8030/01/0131/01/08(2.2)
Artemis AIM VCT33.0072.6010082.5020/02/0131/01/08(2.8)
Bluehone AIM VCT 2 plc41.8067.9010081.9004/12/0031/01/08(3.0)
Northern AIM VCT plc22.0057.4010073.7011/01/0131/12/07(4.6)
Ethical AIM VCT plc (the)17.0053.5010061.3010/04/0031/08/07(6.7)


GENERALIST FUNDS STARTED IN TAX YEARS 01/02
Venture Capital TrustFunds Raised (£m)Net Asset Value (pence)Issue Price (pence)Total Return
(Net Asset Value plus dividends)
(pence)
First trading dayDate of last published NAV figureTotal Return Internal Rate of Return (%)
ProVen Growth and Income VCT plc7.10132.90100233.3031/05/0131/01/0814.9
Baronsmead VCT 4 plc18.40118.10100142.1020/12/0231/12/076.3
Aberdeen Growth Opportunities VCT plc10.00100.90100115.1012/12/0130/11/072.4
Northern 3 VCT plc13.9096.90100113.8017/12/0131/12/072.3
Leisure and Media VCT8.9090.20100110.0008/06/0130/06/071.7
Oxford Technology 34.0095.0010095.0004/04/0231/08/07(0.9)
British Smaller Technology Companies VCT 2 plc6.8081.2010091.7012/04/0130/09/07(1.4)
Electra Kingsway15.1078.7010090.9025/01/0230/09/07(1.8)
Aberdeen Growth VCT I24.4074.6010084.5010/04/0131/07/07(2.7)
Noble Income & Growth VCT plc2.7078.7010078.7027/03/0231/12/07(4.1)
Quester VCT 518.4070.7010074.2024/12/0131/10/07(5.1)
Hygea VCT plc7.0060.2010061.5019/04/0230/06/07(9.0)


AIM BASED FUNDS STARTED IN TAX YEARS 01/02
Venture Capital TrustFunds Raised (£m)Net Asset Value (pence)Issue Price (pence)Total Return
(Net Asset Value plus dividends)
(pence)
First trading dayDate of last published NAV figureTotal Return Internal Rate of Return (%)
Unicorn AIM VCT plc35.0071.70100110.7005/11/0131/01/081.9
Pennine Downing AIM VCT 2 plc7.0057.2010070.7031/05/0131/01/08(5.5)
Close Second AIM VCT plc8.9040.0010060.6005/04/0131/01/08(7.4)


AIM BASED FUNDS STARTED IN 02/03
Venture Capital TrustFunds Raised (£m)Net Asset Value (pence)Issue Price (pence)Total Return
(Net Asset Value plus dividends)
(pence)
First trading dayDate of last published NAV figureTotal Return Internal Rate of Return (%)
Phoenix AIM VCT10.5087.90100110.9008/01/0331/12/072.2


AIM BASED FUNDS STARTED IN 03/04
Venture Capital TrustFunds Raised (£m)Net Asset Value (pence)Issue Price (pence)Total Return
(Net Asset Value plus dividends)
(pence)
First trading dayDate of last published NAV figureTotal Return Internal Rate of Return (%)
Close Brothers AIM VCT plc 'D' Shares15.00108.40100120.5016/03/0431/01/085.1
Unicorn AIM VCT plc Series 215.6089.50100106.3005/02/0431/01/081.6


GENERALIST FUNDS STARTED IN 04/05(2)
Venture Capital TrustFunds Raised (£m)Net Asset Value (pence)Issue Price (pence)Total Return
(Net Asset Value plus dividends)
(pence)
First trading dayDate of last published NAV figureTotal Return Internal Rate of Return (%)
Aberdeen Growth Opportunities VCT2 plc7.70109.50100117.5017/02/0530/06/060.0
Arc Growth Company VCT plc1.10131.10100131.5030/06/0530/11/070.0
Close Income & Growth VCT plc45.4089.2010097.7007/10/0431/12/070.0
Core VCT 1 plc11.0096.8010099.9004/04/0530/09/070.0
Downing Protected VCT II plc10.2095.9010098.4005/04/0531/10/070.0
Downing Protected VCT III plc10.2095.9010098.4013/04/0531/10/070.0
Eclipse VCT 2 plc18.60120.30100125.6021/03/0531/10/070.0
Eclipse VCT plc31.30115.90100129.6004/08/0430/11/070.0
Elderstreet VCT plc 'C' Shares1.5095.1010099.6005/04/0531/12/060.0
Electra Kingsway VCT 2 plc34.2099.80100103.3003/12/0430/09/070.0
Foresight 2 VCT plc19.50100.20100105.8024/12/0430/09/070.0
Foresight 3 VCT plc31.5094.00100106.0004/04/9630/09/070.0
Foresight 4 VCT plc35.00102.4091114.9030/07/0430/11/070.0
Ingenious Music VCT plc15.1091.0010091.0005/04/0530/11/070.0
Keydata Income VCT 1 plc4.1097.3010098.6023/06/0530/11/070.0
Keydata Income VCT 2 plc4.1097.3010098.6023/06/0530/11/070.0
Matrix Income & Growth VCT plc22.10110.80100115.0008/10/0430/09/070.0
Neptune Calculus Income & Growth VCT plc3.80102.20100107.2007/02/0514/09/070.0
Oxford Technology 4 VCT plc7.10111.00100111.0008/09/0431/08/070.0
Puma VCT 2 plc8.30108.30100109.2009/06/0530/11/070.0
Puma VCT plc12.10108.10100109.0029/04/0530/11/070.0
Triple Point VCT plc3.3094.4010096.7030/06/0530/09/070.0
Ventus VCT plc15.0094.3010099.7015/03/0531/12/070.0


AIM BASED FUNDS STARTED IN 04/05(2)
Venture Capital TrustFunds Raised (£m)Net Asset Value (pence)Issue Price (pence)Total Return
(Net Asset Value plus dividends)
(pence)
First trading dayDate of last published NAV figureTotal Return Internal Rate of Return (%)
Artemis AIM VCT 2 plc40.0080.1010084.1014/12/0431/01/080.0
Framlington AIM VCT plc24.6074.9010087.9002/12/0431/12/070.0
Invesco Perpetual AIM VCT plc24.8080.4010092.4003/08/0431/12/070.0
Keydata AIM VCT plc14.3089.9010099.9029/10/0431/01/080.0
New Century AIM VCT plc8.50142.30100144.5024/03/0531/08/070.0
Noble AIM VCT plc11.0097.30100106.8029/03/0531/01/080.0
Pennine AIM VCT 5 plc22.7078.7010082.2011/02/0531/01/080.0
Phoenix VCT plc 'C' Shares5.2097.50100104.5008/01/0531/12/070.0
Unicorn AIM VCT II plc22.80101.10100102.1007/01/0531/01/080.0


GENERALISTS AND SPECIALISTS STARTED 05/06(2)
Venture Capital TrustFunds Raised (£m)Net Asset Value (pence)Issue Price (pence)Total Return
(Net Asset Value plus dividends)
(pence)
First trading dayDate of last published NAV figureTotal Return Internal Rate of Return (%)
Aberdeen Growth Opportunities VCT plc 'C' Shares15.0095.0010099.2015/02/0630/11/070.0
Baronsmead VCT 4 plc 'C' Shares20.0098.30100103.3010/03/0631/12/070.0
Chrysalis VCT plc 'D' Shares0.50104.10100107.4028/03/0631/10/070.0
Chrysalis VCT plc 'E' Shares0.6093.3010096.6028/03/0631/10/070.0
Close Technology & General VCT plc 'C' Shares35.5092.6010095.6004/01/0630/09/070.0
Core VCT II plc16.5097.9010099.4012/01/0630/09/070.0
Core VCT III plc16.5097.8010099.3010/03/0630/09/070.0
Downing Protected VCT IV plc21.7095.6010096.6031/01/0631/05/070.0
Downing Protected VCT V plc21.7095.6010096.6008/02/0631/05/070.0
Eclipse VCT 3 plc29.5096.7010098.9014/10/0531/12/070.0
Eclipse VCT 4 plc29.5096.7010098.9014/10/0531/12/070.0
Edge Performance VCT plc6.4086.1010092.1011/04/0631/08/070.0
Electra Kingsway VCT 3 plc35.10100.00100102.5001/12/0530/09/070.0
IBIS Media VCT 1 plc4.7095.0010095.0005/04/0631/10/070.0
Ingenious Music VCT 2 plc26.5094.5010094.5014/02/0630/11/070.0
Limelight VCT plc5.6092.3010092.9005/04/0630/09/070.0
Matrix Income & Growth 2 VCT plc 'C' Shares9.2098.50100100.0016/12/0531/10/070.0
Matrix Income & Growth 3 VCT plc20.0096.9010099.2026/01/0630/09/070.0
Neptune-Calculus Income & Growth VCT plc 'C' Shares8.4094.5010095.5014/02/0614/09/070.0
Northern VCT plc 'C' Shares20.7092.5010094.5006/01/0630/06/070.0
ProVen Growth and Income VCT plc 'C' Shares25.0091.8010096.8012/01/0631/01/080.0
Puma VCT III plc19.5098.8010098.8019/05/0630/11/070.0
Puma VCT IV plc19.5097.5010097.5019/05/0630/11/070.0
Ventus 2 VCT plc10.3094.7010097.2017/03/0631/12/070.0
Ventus 3 VCT plc10.3094.7010097.2017/03/0631/12/070.0


AIM BASED FUNDS STARTED IN 05/06(2)
Venture Capital TrustFunds Raised (£m)Net Asset Value (pence)Issue Price (pence)Total Return
(Net Asset Value plus dividends)
(pence)
First trading dayDate of last published NAV figureTotal Return Internal Rate of Return (%)
Baronsmead AIM VCT plc16.8094.8010098.5013/03/0631/01/080.0
Bluehone AIM VCT 2 plc 'C' Shares3.0088.6010090.6014/02/0631/01/080.0
Close IHT AIM VCT plc 'A' Shares7.3087.1010090.5025/01/0631/01/080.0
Close IHT AIM VCT plc 'B' Shares17.7087.1010090.5025/01/0631/01/080.0
Close Second AIM VCT plc 'C' Shares8.2088.1010091.0002/03/0631/08/080.0
Close Second AIM VCT plc 'D' Shares12.0088.1010091.0002/03/0631/01/080.0
Framlington AIM VCT 2 plc30.9079.9010085.9021/12/0528/12/070.0
Keydata AIM VCT plc 'C' Shares17.9088.5010091.0018/01/0631/01/080.0
Pennine AIM VCT 6 plc26.7085.6010087.7029/12/0531/01/080.0
Unicorn AIM VCT II plc 'C' Shares12.5087.3010088.3004/01/0631/01/080.0


GENERALISTS AND SPECIALISTS STARTED 06/07(2)
Venture Capital TrustFunds Raised (£m)Net Asset Value (pence)Issue Price (pence)Total Return
(Net Asset Value plus dividends)
(pence)
First trading dayDate of last published NAV figureTotal Return Internal Rate of Return (%)
Aberdeen Growth Opportunities VCT 2 plc 'S' Shares4.9095.3010095.3005/04/0730/06/070.0
Apollo VCT 1 plc8.9094.5010094.5017/10/0631/10/070.0
Apollo VCT 2 plc8.9094.5010094.5017/10/0631/10/070.0
Close Enterprise VCT plc20.0094.5010095.2005/04/0730/09/070.0
Core VCT IV plc11.1092.8010092.8012/03/0730/09/070.0
Core VCT V plc11.1093.0010093.0024/04/0730/09/070.0
Downing Protected VCT VI plc9.1095.1010095.1015/03/0731/07/070.0
Downing Protected VCT VII plc9.1095.1010095.1017/04/0731/07/070.0
Edge Performance VCT plc 'C' Shares13.3094.7010094.7011/04/0731/08/070.0
Electra Kingsway VCT plc 'C' Shares8.3092.3010092.3014/03/0730/09/070.0
Foresight 2 VCT plc 'C' Shares14.0094.2010094.2008/01/0730/09/070.0
Ingenious Live VCT 1 plc8.2095.6010095.6020/04/0731/12/070.0
Ingenious Live VCT 2 plc8.2095.6010095.6020/04/0731/12/070.0
Octopus Protected VCT plc27.4095.0010095.0017/10/0631/10/070.0
ProVen VCT plc 'C' Shares14.8090.6010091.6013/03/0731/01/080.0
TP70 VCT plc32.0095.8010095.8026/03/0730/09/070.0


AIM BASED FUNDS STARTED IN 06/07(2)
Venture Capital TrustFunds Raised (£m)Net Asset Value (pence)Issue Price (pence)Total Return
(Net Asset Value plus dividends)
(pence)
First trading dayDate of last published NAV figureTotal Return Internal Rate of Return (%)
Keydata AIM VCT 2 plc4.6093.0010093.0016/04/0731/01/080.0
New Century AIM VCT 2 plc5.7099.0010099.0003/04/0730/09/070.0
Pennine AIM VCT plc 'D' Shares2.7094.5010094.5009/03/0731/12/070.0
Unicorn AIM VCT plc Series 35.0085.6010085.6011/04/0731/01/080.0


GENERALISTS AND SPECIALISTS STARTED 07/08(2)
Venture Capital TrustFunds Raised (£m)Net Asset Value (pence)Issue Price (pence)Total Return
(Net Asset Value plus dividends)
(pence)
First trading dayDate of last published NAV figureTotal Return Internal Rate of Return (%)
Downing Protected VCT VIII plc0.0094.5010094.5011/12/0711/12/070.0
Octopus Titan VCT 1 plc0.0094.5010094.5028/12/0728/12/070.0
Octopus Titan VCT 2 plc0.0094.5010094.5028/12/0728/07/070.0

1 no recent NAV
2 Internal rates of return on these recent VCTs are not shown as they convey little meaning - VCTs are ranked alphabetically.

Source: Tax Shelter Report


Important notes:

Allenbridge believe that the only way to compare funds properly is to incorporate the time value of money through a discounting technique such as the Internal Rate of Return. Adding dividends paid to Net Asset Value does not do the job.

There is only a limited value in this table as you cannot compare AIM funds with general funds nor can a new fund be compared to one that has been running a few years. In general, any fund that holds AIM stocks will look good compared to one whose unquoted holdings are valued conservatively according to British Venture Capital Association guidelines.

As Allenbridge repeat frequently in Tax Shelter Report, the share price is no indicator of value as there is virtually no market for second hand VCT shares- purchasers do not receive full tax reliefs and sellers lose their tax reliefs if they sell within the first three years.

There are many timing and investment valuation issues which inhibit direct comparison of rates of return between VCTs: AIM stocks can be valued at mid-market or at a discount to reflect illiquidity; unquoted investments are valued according to guidelines that are open to interpretation; most VCTs have immature portfolios; VCTs have net asset values declared on different dates